Narrowing

What are we missing?

God's people need to recognize the danger of a narrowed vision — a limited perspective in which parts of who God is and what he is doing in the world no longer fit within your understanding of reality.

Take the assessment →Twenty questions. About ten minutes.

The problem

God's word expands our understanding. The world narrows it.

The forces that produce narrowing do not announce themselves. They subvert doctrine and belief by retraining the instincts and behavior of God's people.

Our stated convictions do not change. We simply stop living them out, because we cannot resist a formation we cannot see.

This is a twenty-question assessment. It names what you have stopped being able to see, and what closed it down.

What gets narrowed

Scripture is what gets narrowed.

God's self-disclosure expands our vision. It shows us a world we could not see by observation alone. As the world's forces close that vision down, we diminish aspects of God's word without deciding to.

This is not atheism. It is a species of fearing man rather than fearing God. The fear does not feel like fear. It feels like prudence.

Three of these close down what you are able to see. The fourth reverses who is permitted to correct you.

01

Vision — You stop seeing where God is working.

The world's story begins to feel complete, and God's word is quietly permitted to say less. Goodness, truth, and beauty outside your own camp become inconvenient to recognize, then awkward, then unthinkable. You are not afraid of God in this. You are afraid of what your own people would say. The clearest sign is not conflict. It is the absence of conflict.

02

Body — You stop seeing whom God is working through.

You sort Christians into the sound and the unsound by standards you did not get from Scripture. Faithfulness in another idiom stops registering as faithfulness. Stephen's opponents could not hear what God had done outside the land and outside the temple, and when they could not refute him they stopped their ears. The judgment of the tribe is nearer than the judgment of God, and it arrives sooner.

03

Horizon — You stop seeing what God has promised to do.

God gave Jeroboam a kingdom. Jeroboam feared for it and built calves to secure what had already been secured. He did not stop believing the promise. He stopped believing it was sufficient. Name what you are working to preserve, and ask what you are afraid would happen if you left God to keep it.

04

Order — You stop letting God's word overrule you.

Interpretive convictions are necessary, and every community that reads Scripture together will develop them. Inversion is what happens when they climb above the text, so that the text is no longer permitted to correct the interpreter. God's order is pressed into the service of ours. A form of piety continues, and that piety is now defined by human rules. You are drawing on God's authority to serve ends God has not authorized.

The full diagnosis — three forces and two conditions — is developed at The Framework →

What you get

See what has closed. Practice opening it again.

The assessment names the narrowing. The book works through the rival orders that produce it and the scriptural practices that widen what has closed.

Assessment

  • Twenty questions. Ten minutes.
  • A written report naming what has narrowed, and how it closed
  • A conversation that will not accept a general answer
  • One practice for each finding

On Earth as in Heaven

  • A short book on how rival orders form God's people
  • Scripture worked closely: Laodicea, Corinth, Jeroboam, Mark 7, Deuteronomy 8
  • The framework, and the practices that widen what has closed
  • Discussion questions throughout

Pricing to be confirmed.

Final assessment pricing will be published after review.

Take the assessment →

Nothing you enter is scored against you, shared, or sent anywhere. There is no mailing list attached to this and no follow-up sequence.

Who wrote this

James Spencer, PhD

James Spencer is president of the D. L. Moody Center and host of the Thinking Christian podcast. He is an Associate Research Fellow at the Kirby Laing Centre for Public Theology and adjunct faculty in Wheaton College's MA in Leadership program, with a PhD in Theological Studies from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School.

He is the author of Serpents and Doves, Christian Resistance, and Trajectories. His forthcoming book is Digital Discernment (InterVarsity Press).

This assessment comes out of that work. It is not a personality test and it is not a quiz. It is an attempt to make one thing visible.

More about James →

The last thing

Stephen's opponents stopped their ears.

They could not refute him, so they covered their ears and rushed at him. That was not unbelief. That was a narrowed vision meeting something it could not hold, and doing the only thing left to it.

This assessment is built to tell you what you cannot see, which means it is built to be unwelcome. If it finds that nothing is costing you anything, it will not congratulate you.

You can stay narrow. Or you can let God's revealed word expand your vision, and learn to observe all that has been commanded by the one to whom all authority in heaven and on earth has been given.

Matthew 28:16–20