← All Episodes

How Should Christians Think About Global Politics? (Robert J. Joustra) | Faith & Politics #19

With Robert J. Joustra

November 17, 2026

·

1:05:24

About this episode

How should Christians think about global politics? Robert J. Joustra joins James Spencer to apply Augustine's order of loves to international relations and Christian nationalism.

Robert J. Joustra, author of Christ and Covenant in Global Politics, explains why international relations is different: there is no sovereign above the nations to enforce justice. Drawing on Augustine, he argues that nations are communities defined by what they love, and that shared loves, not force alone, help explain why the postwar order held. He also reads Deuteronomy 17 as a law the king himself had to obey.

Many Christians either feel overwhelmed by world events or reach for slogans. Joustra presses a slower path: learn about your neighbors first, because you cannot love people you know nothing about. He argues that Christian nationalism responds to something real, a state treated like a subscription service, but that the church already has better answers in its creeds and confessions, if only it would read them.

In this episode:

  • What is anarchy in international relations, and why does it change how we think about justice?
  • Augustine's order of loves (ordo amoris): are nations defined by what they love?
  • Deuteronomy 17 and a king who lives under the law
  • J. D. Vance, America First, and the parable of the Good Samaritan (Luke 10:25–37)
  • What does Christian nationalism see rightly, and why has the church forgotten its own answers?

Guest: Robert J. Joustra, professor of politics at Calvin University and author of Christ and Covenant in Global Politics (IVP Academic).

Get 20% off Christ and Covenant in Global Politics from InterVarsity Press with code IVPPOD20: ivpress.com/christ-and-covenant-in-global-politics

Go deeper: Christians and Politics About Robert J. Joustra: thinkingchristian.org/guests/robert-j-joustra

Thinking Christian is hosted by Dr. James Spencer, president of the D. L. Moody Center and author of Digital Discernment (InterVarsity Press). Each conversation reads the Bible as the final authority for life and faith, questioning the assumptions of our culture, even our Christian culture, so that we don't settle for a narrower vision than God's word offers.

Unsettling convention. Cultivating conviction. Episodes, articles, and questions: thinkingchristian.org About James Spencer: thinkingchristian.org/james The Thinking Christian Framework: thinkingchristian.org/framework Order Digital Discernment: amazon.com

Subscribe: YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify Advertising and partnership inquiries: info@thinkingchristian.org

Discover more Christian podcasts at lifeaudio.com and inquire about advertising opportunities at lifeaudio.com/contact-us.

Transcript

Speaker 1: Hey, everyone.

Speaker 2: Welcome to this episode of Thinking Christian. I'm Dr. James Spencer, and I'm joined today by Robert J. Joustra. He is professor of politics and Spielhof chair at Calvin University, and he's written a book called Christ and Covenant in Global Politics. And so we're going to have a conversation about global politics today and how it relates to Christianity. So welcome to the show, Robert. Really great to have you here.

Speaker 1: Yep. Delighted to be here. Glad that you've had a chance to see it and even read it. What a high honor. So I'm.

Speaker 2: Well, you know, I find it easier to interview people once I've actually read the book. So I do a lot of reading for the show. And it's fantastic. It fills my need to be a huge geek. And so that's been great.

Speaker 1: Well, I'm delighted.

Speaker 2: So we've been doing a series on faith and politics. I'll actually finish up here kind of late November, you know, around midterms, that kind of stuff. We've done a lot of political episodes in the past, but there's not a lot out there on global politics and how Christians should think about global politics. What led you into this space? I mean, obviously there was room there, but why would you be interested?

Speaker 1: Well, there was a lot of room there, actually, as it turned out once I started getting into it. But, you know, you might be able to see, actually, I'm not sure if people watch this on video, but I've actually got.

Speaker 2: A poppy on.

Speaker 1: And that's something that Canadians, it's something that people in the Commonwealth comes out of sort of Great Britain where, between October 24th and November 11th, where on the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month, there's a remembrance of the wars that the countries have fought and the service men and women And, you know, my dad was born, you know, under Nazi occupation in January of 1943 in a little village in Friesland. And so it's not an accident, actually, that my family ended up sort of finding its way to Canada because, of course, he got his village was liberated on April 17th of 1945. And he got his first taste of chocolate or so he tells us some of us aren't sure about the family lore from the Canadian soldiers that that liberated his village. And so there was always kind of two big stories that were kind of in the background that defined my life growing up. And one of them was the story of the war and the story of his family in the war, the experiences of our family, that my dad's name, my last name, my son's last name, finds its place on the wall of the righteous Gentiles. And what was the kind of theology, what was the kind of story of hope in the midst of those enormously dark times. I mean, often when we're thinking historically, you know, it's very easy to kind of think, oh, well, you know, 1943, it was only a few years away. You know, they'd land on the beaches of Normandy in June of 1944. You know, the Canadians would land on Juneau and kind of work up to kind of liberate some of those ports. That's true. But, you know, that's what we know retrospectively. At the time, it looked like the Germans were in a pretty secure position. It didn't look like this was going to change anytime soon. And in fact, if anything, very much the reverse was the case. And so how to live lives of hope in the midst of these incredibly dark and troubled times. And so I grew up both with that kind of, you know, holding the scriptures in the one hand, as it were, and its story of hope, its story of perseverance, its witness absolutely to the suffering of the saints. And then on the other hand, the difficulties of geopolitics, the challenges, the knock on the door, as it were, that we would talk about in my family growing up, you know, that a knock will come at the door and there will be a question of who is in the home and what witness do you give in that moment? And so the question of justice, the question of sort of how to live lives of grateful obedience, how to be followers of Jesus in conflicts between the nations, this is something that I grew up with. It was a very kind of, you know, creedal, very kind of, sort of something straight out of the crib. And, you know, is afresh today. You know, my first semester of college was September of 2001. And so, of course, back then, and it's a hard time to actually explain this to students today, where I say, well, you know, I was Canadian. I live here in the United States now, but I was Canadian then. I still am Canadian, of course. And I said, well, you know, I was in college in Canada in 2001. And I'll tell you, You know, we watched this on the TV, of course, you know, there were no texts going around or anything like that. A friend of mine that I grew up with actually said, just don't go to class, go back to the door, go back to your dorm, turn on the TV. And I tell you, we felt very American that day. And I still do when I think about it. And students today struggle kind of with the emotion of the moment. And I say, you know, we all we all went kind of crazy with with grief, with fear, with rage. And it can be difficult to understand historically those moments if you weren't living in them, in the emotion of them and how they propelled us forward into action. And so that sort of concentrated me even more. I said, well, I've always been interested in history. I've always been interested in politics. I've always been interested in theology. But now it seemed to me that in the post-Cold War world, some new world order was emerging in that moment before my eyes, you know, adolescent that I was in my first year of college. And I didn't know. I mean, in a way, I wrote the book. I mean, they say, you know, all academic work, all writing is kind of, you know, self-therapy and so on.

Speaker 2: Right.

Speaker 1: I didn't know. I'm like, I knew kind of, you know, that scripture spoke about justice. I knew that. And I know how to think about that in Canadian politics or in American politics and how you work with members of parliament or congressmen or senators and you work within the different systems and institutions to lobby for and make changes that we would consider more just. But internationally, I thought, boy, this is not something I know how to think about. And that's actually kind of what I ended up studying and working toward and finding out that, yeah, there were people who had thought about this in the Christian tradition. But a lot of that work was sort of in the 1950s and the 1960s, some of it in the 1980s. But basically, we had not really done a lot of work as an English Christian community in that moment. I mean, I want to be very clear on that as an Anglo Christian community, we hadn't sort of thought about some of that in a really kind of robust way in a couple of decades. And so, you know, that's what brought me to actually work on the book where I said, well, you know what, there isn't, there's just a lot, a lot of stuff out here like this, even when it comes down to what it was assigned to my students. And so I'd really been thinking about it for 20 or 30 years by the time I sort of came to it. And hopefully you'll see, you know, a lot of the notes, a lot of the kind of giants that have come before, but some of them are older. So it's a very personal story, but it's also very much one that I felt we hadn't, had the opportunity to think through as a sort of English Christian church as much as we needed to. And boy, it seems to me that after 9-11, and especially today, we need to start doing that heavy lifting.

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, the world's getting, in some ways, it's getting smaller and smaller. And so we're starting to see, and it's interesting, I think, as I read through and was thinking about justice and You have the nation state that was very much sort of a center for culture and identity, probably even in 2001 when you were just starting college. I was just finishing college. I was just starting my Master of Divinity.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: You know, but you had these sort of it was a little bit more compartmentalized. Yes, you could watch sort of global news on the television. Yes, you could, you know, get out there and surf the web and see things from different places. But it wasn't what we have today. It wasn't the sort of media onslaught where you can basically go online and instantaneously find someone across the globe to talk with and do those things. I'm sure it was there, but it wasn't anywhere near the level that we're doing it now. And so there there is an interesting shift in context that's happening even just through the technological aspects that, you know, what we can see, what we can find, who we can talk to. All of those aspects are changing, which I don't you know, as you think about justice in the nation state, it's it becomes a little more complicated because the nation state is I don't know whether you'd agree with this, but it feels like the nation state has not been displaced totally. but that it is starting to fray along the edges in ways that are noticeable because we're becoming more global citizens.

Speaker 1: So I don't know whether you have any thoughts on that. No, I mean, I think that's absolutely right. I mean, it's a discipleship challenge. The gospel needs to be contextualized in every place and every time. The good news doesn't change, but where we live changes. You know, and I think, you know, what I was intuiting, and I mean, this was not a dramatic insight on my part in 2001, was that the world we had lived in had changed.

Speaker 2: Right.

Speaker 1: And I think we're in another one of those inflection moments now. Right. Where, yes, the post 9-11 world changed, but now also, you know, we are seeing change in this world. And so how do we live as disciples of Jesus Christ in that moment? I think you're right that in 2001, the kind of primary way through which we would look at that lens was through the nation state.

Speaker 2: Right.

Speaker 1: So and I think we're still looking through that lens. So I'm not ready. And I don't it doesn't sound like you are either to call the kind of, you know, the death knell of the nation state. I mean, it's actually resurgent in some ways. But there do also seem to be these other connections and these other awarenesses. And we're part of other communities that we can now maybe even if we've always thought of ourselves as part of them. But, you know, we were never connected to them in a way that we could kind of realize those connections in the same. in the same kind of way. And it creates, you know, a layering of identities, you know, as all human beings are. So you are a citizen of the country in which you live. You have obligations, you know, to that. But you're also a member of a lot of other different communities, including, by the way, I would say a prior community, which is the church, which is the kingdom of God. And that, thanks be to God, is not bounded by a particular political constituency. And so how do we live out those different commitments? And what is the ordering that we should think of them in? And here I invoke very deliberately Augustinian language, because we are not the first people to have asked or wondered about that question.

Speaker 2: Yeah, and you start the book actually with the Ordo Amoris. There's a quote from Augustine, and so you sort of riff on that in your introduction to the chapter. How do you see that playing into the way that you conceive of justice and international relationships across the board. I mean, obviously, this is sort of a crucial concept, but talk a little bit about the connections in your mind between love in that Ordo and Morris sort of way and justice in the way that it's worked out interpersonally, maybe, and then getting to that sort of international side of it.

Speaker 1: Yeah. So let me, I might somewhat reverse them, but I'll be very brief because I want to kind of pose the problem first. So the reason why, for example, I mean, there are a lot of really good, thoughtful Christian introductions to politics. I wouldn't diminish them for a second. I'm teaching introduction to politics at Calvin University right now. I'm teaching David Coyce's book, Political Visions and Illusions, who, by the way, I read a draft of in 2001 when I was a student at Redeemer University.

Speaker 2: Oh, very cool.

Speaker 1: I'm teaching Bethany and Kristen's book on the justice calling. I've got Hopeful Realism from Micah Watson and Jesse Covington and Brian McGrath. These are really good books. But you know what they don't really address because it's a different kind of conversation is international relations, world politics. Why? Because in global politics, the problem is that there's a condition that exists at the domestic level that doesn't exist at the international level. And that's this thing called sovereignty. So when we go internationally, we have this problem. And this is not like, you know, a theoretical or kind of theological. It's kind of a sort of empirical observation. There's a problem of anarchy. And, you know, when I hear that and when my students hear that, they all think, oh, you know, it's the walking dead. It's the war of all against all. You know, it's the apocalypse. All anarchy means in the literature is that there is no overarching, sovereign, coercive authority to rule on justice in the way in which domestically there is. You know, if I'm driving around, my five-year-old is very interested right now in how much I speed and I wish there was a way for me to hide the speed dollar from him. He's like, you are one mile per hour over. And I'm like, you know, they don't really care.

Speaker 2: It's more of a guideline.

Speaker 1: When it gets into the five to 10 range, why don't you come to me? But I think, you know, at this point we're doing okay. But you know, if you're breaking those kinds of rules, I mean, we all know there's a kind of, there's an escalatory process for my compliance, right? And eventually, by the way, if I simply will not comply, I will be required to comply. That's how the state works. That's how sovereignty works. It doesn't work that way in the international system. So how do we adjudicate claims of justice? Okay, here we come to Augustine. And Augustine talks about the nation. He talks about the political community as a community of ordered loves. What defines it, and by the way, this is very much contra the resurgence around blood and soil nationalism that we have around the world today. by the way. So I don't need to pick on any particular country. This is, how should we say, a very promiscuous political reality in the world. But what Augustine says is he says, the quality of a political community, Ordo Amoris, is determined by the ordering of its loves. It determines what is it that we love, what is it that we are committed to. And that actually is the thing that grounds our identity. What's genius about this, by the way, is that it can separate out, not in a way that I think Augustine necessarily intended, but in a way in which a lot of democratic and sort of, you know, broadly, here I'll use the term liberal theory, thinks about politics. It can separate the ultimate from the proximate, okay? So you could have a political community that is committed very strongly to certain kinds of loves, to certain kinds of principles, but actually has some, how should we say, the state- does not require you to have the underlying rationale for them. That sounds very abstract. Let me make it very practical. Because you know what? The ordering of our loves is not a super abstract idea. In fact, many different states and communities around the world have such a thing. They have a document. They actually write it down. They actually make it really hard to change that document because they don't trust the kids. Right. You know, if the kids really, oh, maybe we made a mistake on this, but we're going to need you to be really sure we made a mistake on this. We're going to make it really hard for you to do it. And they call them things like constitutions. Right. A radical idea. But actually, you go to Deuteronomy 17 and you find that this is a very similar thing that God has instituted there. He actually makes the king, by the way, this is the this is one of the great initial insights. Thomas Paine writes about it during the American Revolution, where he says, you know, there's a high law that the king is required to write by hand. that he's subject to, right, in the context of Deuteronomy 17. Well, what is that? That's a constitution. That's a written law. And in the case of ancient Israel, of course, it was the law, capital L, you know, that does not come. In the ancient world, that law came out of the God-king. But in the Israelite world, right, that law actually came from God, who was the true king, right? And the king who served in Israel was actually a servant of that law.

Speaker 2: Right?

Speaker 1: This is where we get the old terms public servant from. You hold political power, sure, but it is power paired with vulnerability. It is power paired with responsibility because you are under the law. Okay, so this is the kind of way that these Augustinian ideas have come forward. And that actually gives you some room to maneuver in international relations, I think. Because what you then have are national communities, political communities, we call them states today in the modern world, that are committed to proximate common loves to which their community, by the way, when we say proximate, sometimes people think, oh, well, so they're not very important. No, no, no, my friends. These are matters of life and death, right? The fundamental equality of men and women, right? The right to association, the freedom of religion or belief, right? These are the kinds of things that people live and die for. I should know, I wear a poppy here in homage to just the sorts of men and women who gave their life to these very proximate and yet nonetheless quite fundamental political commitments. And then the question that you have in international relations is how do you engage in relations between these very diverse nations? Because some of them, by the way, are going to be, you know, they're Hindu, they're coming out of the Vedic tradition. Some of them are going to be more Confucian, they're going to be more Buddhist, they're going to be Orthodox Christians, they're going to be very secular, you know, maybe laicite, you know, as in sort of some of the more Parisian French experiences. How can you do diplomacy with these people? Right? Well, you do it in the way, in the same way, actually, that Augustine models it, which is you engage in relationships out of a common sense of common love, right? Of common loves. And this, by the way, explains, right? It has an explanatory feature. Why is it that the United States of America and Europe and Canada and Australia and Japan, you know, because by the way, some people might say to me, oh, well, they're all kind of vaguely European. I Not a lot of European Europeanness going on there. And yet, you know, when you read their constitutions, when you see in which in the way in which the ordering of their societies, the ordering of their loves, you say, oh, yeah, well, it's not entirely American. That's true. Right. And yet you've got to say, boy, a lot of it rhymes. It sounds pretty familiar. You can go and live, as I did in Japan for a year. And by the way, absolutely look like a foreigner.

Speaker 2: Right.

Speaker 1: You know, I don't look Japanese. This is true. This is true. And yet the ordering of Japanese political society, the rule of law, the way in which that, very familiar to me as a Canadian, very familiar, actually committed to very, very similar principles. And you know what? Ideally, what that means in this kind of diplomatic presentation is that if we're going to do work with other states, with other nations around the world, the folks that it's going to be the easiest, because there's no sovereignty. So nobody's going to make us get along. Nobody's going to require us to fulfill our obligations and our treaties. Right. But generally speaking, the conditions under which fidelity and trust are going to be the highest are the people with whom we share these very basic, proximate, yet very basic and fundamental convictions. And that's been the story of the last 75 or 80 years or so, I think, of the post-war order. I don't want to be too idealistic and say, oh, well, it's all been you know, the ideas that we're committed to in common. It's been that, it has been that, it's been important. It was American power and American force, right? The victorious allies after the Second World War, which I also would like to mention included Canada, you know, that were able to enforce that peace in international relations. No question that force is a credible and consistent component. And yet at the same time, it was not only force, right? It was not only American power that took the other great powers of the world, the Europeans that had been at each other's throats for hundreds of years, even countries like India that were inducted into and now are such an important part of the community of nations. It was not only American force. I would go so far as to say it was not primarily American power that did it. It was that people did not challenge American supremacy because American supremacy, quite frankly, suited the way in which they thought about the world. It fit actually with their own sense of convictions. How was it, how Kissinger always put it, the Germans, they're either at your feet or they're at your throats. And I could say this as a Dutchman. And to a sense, why is it that the Germans have spent the last 80 years at the feet of the United States? Why have they been so pliant in the international system? Comparatively speaking, By the way, right. We fought two world wars with these guys.

Speaker 2: That's right.

Speaker 1: We know they know they've got it in them. You know, we've got a lot of empirical evidence historically. Why was that? Well, the reason was because actually the American led international order that was committed to these same loves that was committed. This was actually something that they were actually happy to voluntarily submit to, because as it turned out, it was a good recipe for justice. It was not the best. It's not Christ's return. Oh, it's full of hypocrisy and injustice, packed full of it. And yet, comparatively, as Churchill liked to say, the best thing that we have, you know, the best of a bad bunch, approximately the best sort of form of thing. And so I think that's the kind of debate that we're having today. Do we still believe in these orderings? Is this still the right way of thinking about it? Has the American, for example, investment, into that system, which nobody would deny has been enormously extensive in blood and treasure over the last 80 years, you know, has the United States been taken advantage of? Is it time for the bill to come due? Is it time for people to contribute more? If we really love this, should we put our money where our mouth is? And here, let me say as a Canadian, yes, we should. Right. Yes. Yeah.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Let me ask a couple of followups. Cause I think, um, What came to mind when I was reading through the book and thinking through the anarchy that you spoke of, I'll just bring it down to a really simple level. It's almost like being out in public and deciding you're not going to yell at someone else's children, right? You see them misbehaving, but you just, and you want to say something, but intuitively you're like, no, that's not, that's not a diplomatic thing to do.

Speaker 1: Right.

Speaker 2: I'm sure the parents will you know care for this right and and but there does come a point i can remember we were standing in an airport and i was watching this uh little toddler and he was just sort of running around you know in the airport you know parents are disheveled they're getting luggage they're doing all that kind of stuff and so i see him run away and i was just watching him tracking him because i'm like if he doesn't go to his grandpa who i had seen with them earlier i'm like i'll say something i'll figure out what to do here it turned out he went to his grandpa but i think There is some sense of those sort of situations that you experience as a parent with kids and watching other parents with their kids that you start to understand the sort of anarchy you're talking about. You have no sovereignty in that situation. It's not that it's not your responsibility. It's that your responsibility is so far back and you don't really have authority in the moment that you have to exercise your responsibilities in a very different way. So I think that tracks with the way you were talking about anarchy and sovereignty.

Speaker 1: Yeah, I think that's right. I mean, where you have both power and authority, but also responsibility and where you are likely to make good on it, right? Because that's the other thing. You know, Reinhold Niebuhr, one of the great public theologians of America's 20th century, writes this wonderful book on the irony of American history, where he says one of the things Americans have to be regularly reminded of especially in the latter half of the 20th century coming out of the wars, that American power can often do less than we imagine that it can. Right. We need great humility. Now, I have to say that being born in Canada, that was that was a lesson that I received osmotically. Right. Nobody I don't have to go into any seminars in Canada. I don't have to go into the Pearson Building and Foreign Affairs and say, well, hold on, guys. Can Canada fix this situation? Right. Nobody's asking if Canada could fix this situation. That's an insane question. You know, we might be able to proximately contribute. I mean, Canada is a wealthy and powerful country. Unquestionably, it has obligations and responsibilities. But there are profound limitations, and they have to be weighed up against other sorts of obligations, including, by the way, the national interest, which I speak of in this book. I often, you know, I sometimes joke about to some of my friends here in the United States where they say, well, you know, we're interested in America, America first. And I say, well, of course you're interested in America first. What should American foreign policy be? America second? Like, I'm confused. America third? You know, of course American national interest is important. The debate is what is in America's national interest.

Speaker 2: That's right.

Speaker 1: It's the combination of not only material considerations, which are real, right, but also in security considerations and considerations of anarchy, but also considerations of what is American identity And who are we and what do we stand for in the world? And what are the sorts of things that actually when they happen, we will look back on and say, now that was an abomination for which in fact, we have some moral complicity. We could have acted damnably difficult as it may have could have been in such a limited way. And yet we know because of who we are, right? Because of what we're committed to. Again, it comes back to our loves, right? If all we care about is material security and the maximization of American power, then okay. But I would suggest to you that those are not self-defining terms. I mean, what is American power? If we know we're pursuing America's role in the world, we can't even answer those questions. They don't have purely secular answers. They don't have purely material answers. They have to do with, I think, the thing that Martin Luther King called the promissory note in the American Declaration of Independence. You know, the way in which the genius of the original architects, having just celebrated 250 years, was in part that they did not understand the moral capaciousness, the moral vision of the very document that they themselves penned. It's for us to work out.

Speaker 2: Right.

Speaker 1: That's part of it, too. Right. That's America first, by the way. That's American identity. And I think it's part of both of those conversations.

Speaker 2: You know, when you see these trends of sort of blood and sand, as you, I think, refer to our blood and ground. sort of coming up in a number of different pockets. Part of my read on that has been, this is just the outworking of the order of loves apart from a love of the triune God, right? There's no other way to think that through when your nation is suffering, when you're seeing the sort of global movements that are happening, you now almost have to re-entrench to maintain some sort of bordered identity, um, within a nation state. But I also wonder how you think about the conception of the order of loves more popularly and even politically. Um, you know, we did an episode on JD Vance had talked about the order of loves and he sort of construed it as a sequence, right? You know, first you do this, then you do this, then you do this, then you do this. And eventually you get over here. And I think that that more popular conception of these orders of love is actually incorrect. I don't think that's what Augustine was saying. I've likened it to the way we change our movements and our breathing and our communication patterns. When we're scuba diving, you're completely immersed in the love of God. And so that animates then differently the way that you love all of these other things. It doesn't preclude any of those loves, but it conditions it deeply. And it, when we construe it as a concentric, you know, sort of a this, then this, then this, then this, and a sequential line, it just seems to me that we do get somewhere where America first, which I agree with you, there needs to be that in foreign policy, but it starts to become a little bit more of a fetish and a little bit more of a centralized love than maybe it should be. Is there anything to that? Just, I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts on it.

Speaker 1: Yeah. So I agree with you. And I think, by the way, so does the Pope.

Speaker 2: Always good to be in agreement with the Pope. I mean, come on.

Speaker 1: Well, you know, I was going to say they read Augustine, too. You know, in fact, the Catholics would tell us that actually maybe he was theirs first. And I would point out that actually with the Reformation, he's kind of all of ours.

Speaker 2: Yeah. He belongs to everybody. Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah. But yeah, no, no, I agree with you. I mean, the idea in which you only have these sets of moral concerns, and then you open a door, and once you've fulfilled those, you open a door to another set of moral concerns, and then you open a door to another set of moral concerns. You know, it's just not the way I read Torah. You know, it's not the way that the law of God seems to push the people of Israel, you know, which, by the way, you know, we might say, well, the civil and ceremonial law per, you know, the book of Acts, you know, these don't These don't necessarily endure, but the moral law does, per the book of Acts, right? So we're not, you know, all going around and kind of, you know, doing the civil and ceremonial and circumcision. I mean, this is literally the debate in the first church council in Jerusalem, right? But the moral law is enduring. You know, we follow Jesus as he follows the law, and he shows us the true meaning of the law, which seems to include a lot of things like the parable of the Good Samaritan. It seems to include a lot of things like thinking about the widow and the orphan and the poor. It seems to include a lot of things about thinking about people that are actually outside of our tribe. I mean, this is actually one of the things in those, you know, 105 words in the parable of the Good Samaritan that Jesus is actually, remember, he's having a debate about the law. This is how they get there. You know, what do you, you know, how do you read it? You know, love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, and mind. Love the neighbor as yourself. On this, all the law and the prophets command. Well, I've kept the law, says the teacher. So who is my neighbor? you know, so then he tells them the story, right? And in the story, one of the things to notice, and it often kind of falls a little askance on sort of North Atlantic 21st century years, is that he sort of, Jesus makes kind of some hard comments about not only the ethnic purity of the Jewish people, because right, the Levite, who's a Jew of the Jews, you know, right through the heart of the center, the priest, the religious purity, right? You know, and who comes out the person who is both a total religious outcast, right? Samaritans still exist in the world today. I think there's fewer than a thousand of them in the north of Israel and in Lebanon, right? A total religious outcast and a total ethnic outcast, right? Somebody who's not part of, and he comes out and Jesus says, you know, while he binds him up and he takes care of him, who was the neighbor? Who was the neighbor? There's a lot of stuff going on, I think, in that parable that Jesus is pushing not only his audience on, but also our audience on to say, actually, you know what? The love of God is not a kind of sequential ordering. There are trade-offs in politics. I don't want to deny that. And I think that's one of the insights that J.D. Vance is trying to articulate. That there are trade-offs in terms of he's trying to kind of, I think, communicate a kind of Reinhold Niebuhr, the irony of American history, which is politics can do a lot, but actually it cannot do everything. And so we need to have a moral conversation about where our responsibilities lie, why we will prioritize certain kinds of things over other kinds of things. And quite frankly, that's the reason we have elections. because people need to think about that amongst themselves. And that ordering might need to change from season to season, because countries also enter different contexts. It may have been, by the way, that in 1993, in my home country of Canada, we were absolutely right, sitting on a massive deficit to gut the Canadian army down to the absolute bare bones, because by the way, the thing had just ended called the Cold War. So everybody was spending the defense dividends, right? Now, we're probably wrong to make that same set of assumptions and priorities in the national conversations in 2026. And it's time, as the Americans have encouraged us, and as I think they are right to do, to push harder on that and say, actually, it's time to invest in this thing that we have atrophied. We all spent the dividend in the 90s. We all thought that it was a good idea. There were certain kinds of assumptions about the way the world was going. I actually don't think they were stupid, but they were wrong, right? And that's easy to say in hindsight. Sometimes you say, oh, you know, these people, they were so naive. How could they ever have imagined Well, actually, you know, if you lived in the 90s and you did and I did, there were some good reasons to be encouraging about this. You know, the Soviet Union had fallen apart. The American experiment was clearly ascended. The two mortal enemies over the course of the massive Second World War, Japan and Germany, had actually become our best friends. So economically productive was Japan that in the 1980s, everybody was anxious about not the Chinese, but the Japanese overtaking the American economy. Right. Victims of their own success. Right. It actually looked like there was going to be a groundswell. You know, you read Francis Fukuyama, The End of History, and you're sitting in 1991 and you say, I don't know, the evidence looks pretty good. It's not the dumbest argument I've ever heard.

Speaker 2: 2026.

Speaker 1: Yeah, it doesn't look right. It was it was it was the wrong call. It was wrong. But now we've got to reinvest and reorder in that way. And so this is why I say this. This is what's so resilient about democracies. You know, I am not a romantic about autocracy, as you get from reading. But this is what's so resilient about democracies, because we actually do need to have the capacities to renegotiate. Right. Not the fundamental ordering of our lives, not rebuild the American Constitution, but reprioritize the tradeoffs of how we express those underlying moral principles in the present day. And that's just good old fashioned politics. That's going to look different in 1995 than it did in 2005. That's going to look today in the American midterm elections. And that takes prudence. That takes wisdom. And by the way, I also think reasonable Christians will disagree on that. And I think there's a lot of space for that possibility of disagreement.

Speaker 2: Yeah, it's really, I think that's a good way to put it. I appreciate the trade-offs idea. I think that as we're looking internationally, those trade-offs are just sort of exponential. And so most of us, myself included, don't know enough about our own history, right? Our American history certainly don't know enough about the histories of these other nations or their capabilities. And so international relations becomes this sort of blurry, we know we have to do it and we're glad someone's doing it. But when we hear things, we have no idea whether that's a good thing, a bad thing, whether this is making our nation and the world healthier or sicker at any given moment. Like we don't understand even enough to gauge whether those trade-offs are appropriate trade-offs or whether these trade-offs are inappropriate. And so I think that's a really good it's a good summary. And I'm wondering if you have thoughts on, as we're looking at this, as we're seeking to participate in politics in an appropriate way as Christians, how do we understand? And I think you get at this in chapter eight, that nationalism or globalism from commonwealths to covenantal pluralism. Like to me, that's the chapter where I started getting things clicking like, okay, this is how I need to be thinking about international politics in more of a a structured, frameworked type of way. So maybe you can talk through that just a little bit and help us kind of get some handles.

Speaker 1: Yeah. First off, I'm delighted because that is the chapter that I tried to put it all as it kind of clicks into place. So you really read the book. I mean, you did get it. The first thing that I'd want to say, and I would say this particularly to an American audience, but I would say it to a Canadian or European one, uh, I will say it to a European one next month, uh, as well, um, is that, you know, the world of international relations can be very overwhelming. There is a lot to know. There is a lot of history to know that we often don't. Um, I would often, you know, challenge my own students who would come to me, you know, especially as freshmen full of fire about the injustice, you know, thinking about, you know, maybe Canada's first nations, the 1876, 1951 Indian acts, truth and reconciliation, um, Israel, Palestine, these kind of flashpoints. And I would say, you know what, before we, so I'm like, so 100%, I'm here for, I'm hearing your scripture inspired, your Jesus inspired indignity and injustice. You should have it, right? That's absolutely right. Do you know what it should drive us toward? To learn about our neighbors, right? How can we love our neighbors if we don't know anything about them? Right. That's crazy. You know, that would be like saying, well, you know what? I love my wife. I have no idea what her favorite ice cream is or what she wants for her birthday. You would probably ask, do you.

Speaker 2: Love your wife?

Speaker 1: How good is your relationship with your wife? But in fact, I have an intimate knowledge of all of those things. And why? Because I love her. Right. And this is true, I think, for our neighbors, too. So the first thing I have to say that is if you say you love something, if you love something. Right. And I have the privilege of saying this to 19 year olds where I think, actually, you probably do really love it. And that's why you're here. So we're going to learn about it together. But the first thing we should learn about, by the way, is ourselves. So hard to go out and do international relations. So hard to go out and wonder about what should we do, you know, about Boko Haram in Nigeria or about the Straits of Hormuz or about the Houthis in Yemen. If we actually have no idea where we as Americans, and here I'll say Americans here in the United States of America, where we are standing and who we are, we're relitigating We're renegotiating that, as Americans do, by the way, every couple of generations. I have less anxiety about this, actually, than most of my American friends here. I say sometimes it helps somebody hopping the cedar coming in from Canada to actually talk about the genius of the American experiment and to recover, you know, this very famous phrase that there's nothing wrong with America that can't be fixed by the best of Americas. To recover and to learn about, well, what are our resources to draw from? And who ought we to be in the midst of this? Because I think that's actually one of the things that's on the midterms right now. It's who ought we to be? What are the sorts of people that we ought to be? How will we know what kind of foreign policy to conduct? How will we know what ought to be America's posture in the world? Is the war in Ukraine our problem? Is Taiwan our problem? You know, why would we be committed to it? It's very far away, as a few people in this current administration have actually said. You know, why is it that we ought to be committed to it? I would submit to you that there are not only or even primarily geopolitical answers to that question. There are moral answers to that question. And that is by getting in contact with the best of the American tradition, the best of American political and theological thought, the thought of the church that's indigenous to this place today. And this time, and so I mean that's that's one of the first things that I would do I would say you know there has to be a recovery of confidence. I see this everywhere by the way where I go here I say you know I see this in institutions political educational otherwise I say, actually you know kind of what I feel like I'm reading is. there's a collapse in confidence, right? And on the far left in American politics, I hear that there is the original sin from which Americans will never recover. Everything is derivative of the fact of the enslavement of human beings and nothing is untouched by the sin. Nothing is redeemable. On the far right, I hear that America is losers and suckers, that they have been taken advantage of, that now it's time to kind of, you know, exercise one's own muscular sense of self over and against how we have been taken care of. But you know what? Neither of those things, neither of those things is the United States of America. We must recover the confidence of self, not to ignore, as it were, the sins of the past as though they have never happened. That's not the fifth commandment, honoring our fathers and mothers. But neither... to permit ourselves to fall into a kind of predatory paganism that says that, you know, we have been taken advantage of and are losers and suckers. And now we must get our own. Now we must get our own. Because by the way, that's not the fifth commandment either. You know, I think, you know, it is a little bit like children growing up. When you are young, your parents can do no wrong. You are a hero. They are your heroes. When you are an adolescent, your parents can do no right. You know, they are pariahs. But as we become fully mature adults, we see our parents as through a more mature moral lens, which is sinners who did not always get it right, and yet whom we owe honor, whom we owe deference, right? And so I think that rediscovery, that moment, that's actually the reason why I'm optimistic. I moved to the United States of America, right? I had Canadians tell me like, oh, are you sure? Is this the moment? And I'm like, I am sure. Because by the way, guys, as I sometimes remind them from your kind of perch of moral condescension here north of the 49th parallel, If somehow that experiment goes wrong, Toronto is not going to be far enough. Yeah. Right. So it's time to get our shoulders to the wheel because there is a greatness and there is a genius there. And I believe that is in the process of being recaptured and rearticulated. But I understand that's the case. So I'm sorry, that was a very long sort of.

Speaker 2: No, it's really helpful. But I think that's.

Speaker 1: The first place to go, which is, you know, rediscover through love both where we live and. and who our neighbors are. And then I would say, you know, I often sort of encourage my students, if they're studying politics, you know what, you should study history too. Because, you know, what are we even talking about? This is what I say to the students who are saying, well, I want to study Israel-Palestine. I read this article in the New York Times yesterday. I said, great. That should drive you. Let's get back to it. And by the way, we're not going to start in the 19th. We're going to start in the 20th. We're not going to start in the 20th. We're going to start in the 19th century. Or even better, we're going to go further back still and we're going to read the histories and we're going to read the stories and we're going to feel the dissonance and we're going to work them through in the way that the arc works. Because you know what that is? That's starting to get to know our neighbors. And then we might get perilously close to loving them, on which all the law and the prophets hang. So this is where I would push it. So Charles Taylor says that the modern age in which we live, it has a pitiless ingratitude toward the past. And I think, you know, a recovery, a really robust recovery of that second summary of the law to love our neighbors as ourselves, to know our neighbors. You know, this might recover. It might be the antidote and a kind of fifth commandment style to some of the pathologies of that more modern moral order. So that's where I would press people. Not right to action. Right. But love is action. Knowing is action. And moving there with a kind of tenderness and curiosity that I think is often all too absent.

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, allowing that sort of tension that we feel about the injustices that we experience today to drive us to understand before we pull levers and push buttons. to try to really get a sense of deep understanding of why this was done, what place it was done in, the context within which a decision was made, and then understanding how that informs the way we act today, I think is a beautiful way to deal with that.

Speaker 1: It's a very conservative idea. This was the Chesterton fence idea.

Speaker 2: The Chesterton fence, yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah, before you tear the fence down, you might want to wonder, hey, why didn't they build that fence? And I think the problem today is we're tearing down all kinds of fences. And then subsequently, in a very revolutionary way, by the way, which I don't think Edmund Burke would have been terribly excited about, you know, and then six months, six years, 60 years later, we discover, oh, man, that's why our grandparents put that fence there.

Speaker 2: Yeah. Right.

Speaker 1: But now the damage is done. Right. So an invitation to a kind of tender curiosity about our parents. That's, I think, what's there in the Fifth Commandment. By the way, the second part of that Fifth Commandment, honor your father and mother so that. you may live long in the land the Lord your God has given you, right? I think there's real political insight there.

Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah. Let me, I have two other topics I want to explore. And so the first one, the first one is around sort of Christian nationalism a bit, and this blood and ground idea and how you think that helps and hinders us from our you know, sort of international relationships. And just to sort of give you a sense of my perspective on this, I always have trouble applying Christian to anything like nation or nationalism or values even. Not because I don't understand what's being said there, but because I don't think we quickly enough make the distinction between something like Christian values and Christian worship, Christian nation and Christian doctrine, right?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Those are two different uses of the word Christian. And I think we often sort of end up merging the two and making no real distinction between them. And that's where I find it to be problematic. And so when we look at Christian nationalism, all we've said, you said in the episode of, you know, there are all these trade-offs within the political realm. My perspective would be that, you know, if Christians were in charge, you're still going to have those exact same trade-offs where you're going to have perhaps is a different moral trajectory, right? You'd like to think that, of course, you know, but do you think that there's anything to or what's your perspective on the sort of, again, going back to that sort of blood and sand movement that we're seeing in various places around the world where you're seeing these resurgence of religious ideas? I mean, even in China, you know, sort of this emergence of, you know, Confucianism kind of rerouting themselves in that. Yeah. Do you think this is going to be helpful when we come to international relationships and say, these are the loves we share, we can negotiate on these? Or do you feel like that's moving us back towards something that's just going to create more religious tension and sort of create a whole different vibe in international relations?

Speaker 1: So I think, I mean, part of the entry for this, and it won't surprise you from what I heard, that I find really helpful is David Coy's book, Political Visions and Illusions.

Speaker 2: Great.

Speaker 1: Yeah. One of the things that he talks about when he's talking about these different ideologies of the modern West is he says, you know, at the heart of them is actually, and this is the kind of, this is the way the biblical category of idolatry works, right? At the heart of them is actually a genuine insight about the creation, right? And so I actually think, so when I talk to my, how should we say, Christian nationalist curious friends, and I say, actually, part of what they are, part of what they are articulating, part of what I think is drawing them is part of the insight, which was, you know, we had increasingly begun to think, you know, I think, you know, at a kind of, you know, very late liberal, kind of very secular world of the state, almost like it was just another corporate provider. You know, Alistair McIntyre talks about it as killing for the state is being asked to kill for the telephone company. You know, and I think, you know, well, you know, do I do I really have that kind of relationship to the telephone company? I'm not sure I want to live and die for it. I actually think if I don't like this company today, I'll just go and I'll I'll be with another company tomorrow. And actually, you did begin to see some of those ideas around citizenship emerge. Right. And actually, in the very wealthy, you do see that people have sort of, you know, luxurious ideas. subsequent citizenships, depending on what transaction they're trying to apply for in the present circumstance. And I think what McIntyre is putting his finger on there is the thing that the nationalists see, that the national community, the state, is not like another service provider, right? It's not like the telephone company, right? It's actually something that binds, and by the way, has, by definition, a monopoly on coercive force. Literally, it's part of the kind of textbook definition on it. that binds a community together out of a commitment to common loves, right? But also demands a kind of sacrifice, right? And when we see like, oh, well, I pay my taxes to the government and then in return, I get these services, you know, just like any other service that I have, just like my cable company, just like my Netflix account. I pay this and I get this service. And I think what they're reacting against is a picture of political community like that. And I think they're right to react against it. I actually think they're seeing something. That's not what the state is. That's not what the political community is. There has to be some kind of moral vocabulary. There has to be some way of talking about a commitment to a political community that's something more than my Netflix account. And we know this. Desmond Tutu has this wonderful story that he recalled from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa. And they're going and they're telling these stories of apartheid in South Africa. It's in the books. You probably... I heard the story, you know, I, you know, he tells the story and people say, hey, you know what, we've noticed you've been opening up these proceedings with very long prayers, you know. it's a bit much. It's a lot of Jesus.

Speaker 2: This is a state function. Can we bring the Jesus's per.

Speaker 1: Minute down just a little bit and just kind of open the proceedings? He says, OK, I take your point. And so he does it. He opens up very briefly. Brief prayer.

Speaker 2: There you go.

Speaker 1: The testimonies pursue. Right. And here's the thing. He calls a halt to the proceedings because he says these proceedings, we cannot bear the weight of these proceedings. The moral vocabulary of the secular liberal state is not sufficient to bear the weight of it. We must come to God in prayer. We must beg for his mercy and forgiveness of the atrocities that we have visited one upon another in this community, right? And on some level, we know this. The state, it is powerful and it is good and it does justice. And yet in the here and now, we know that if we compare the justice of the state to the justice of what we read of God, the true king who comes to make all things new, it is a pale facsimile. What can the state do after atrocity? Well, it can have remembrances. It can set up holidays. It can even have reparations. It can put money in bank accounts. Do you know what it can't do? It cannot resurrect sons and daughters. It cannot bring us back our mothers and our fathers who have been robbed from us by the atrocities that we have wrecked upon each other. That waits for another day and another king and a true justice. And so I think one of the things that the nationalists have seen is they've seen that actually the secular liberal vocabulary that has a very transactional relationship, a very Netflix relationship to the state, That is not a sufficient way of thinking about political order. That is not something that you live and die for. Right. That's just a subscription that you cancel over here and start up over there. And they're trying to find vocabulary that helps us do that. Now, here's the good news. The Christian tradition has that vocabulary.

Speaker 2: Right. Exactly.

Speaker 1: It has a way of thinking about this. We actually don't need to reinvent this out of whole cloth and say, gosh, I wonder if how we would think about as God who is the true king, Christ who is the true king, and yet these earthly sovereigns who have within their remit a kind of proximate political authority to in some pale way, and yet nonetheless in a very real and profound way, execute a version of that justice, how might we sort of negotiate those loyalties? We literally have 2,000 years of Christian social and political thought wrestling over those same questions. The crisis, the tragedy to me, the reason why I think Christian nationalism has permeated the evangelical community, not just in the United States of Cameroon, but in the Netherlands with Gerrit Wilders and the AFD. You're starting to see it in Britain and all of these other places. The reason why is honestly that there has been a collapse of catechesis in the Christian church that, you know, that not only have we forgotten our political history, we have forgotten our religious history as well. To the point that I am a member of the Christian Reformed Church of North America, and we have now created a study committee to look at Christian nationalism. And one of the first things that I said is, we have Article 36 of the Belgic Confession. We don't need a new study committee for Christian nationalism. It's literally written out right there. It's actually a couple of nice type paragraphs. We put it all together and we revised it in 1958. Many of the study committees, much of the work of the church, I think today, is simply an act of retrieval and recovery from a church that has lost the gifts of its parents and grandparents, because we have simply not passed them along to our children. So I often see that this is the work actually of pastors and priests and even professors to some degree. It is simply retrieving and to say, I have good news. We are not the first people to have asked this question. And here is the banquet of theological and political history that's in front. You don't have to love it all. Oh, it's full of contradictions and disagreements. And yet there it is. Let us go out. And learn it. And so I think, yes, there's real insight. It's responding to an actual moment in our political history, Christian nationalism. But David Brooks often said this about the Trump administration. He said, you know, he's actually asking a lot of the right questions. Right. But the answers. Oh, my goodness.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah. But the answers we can do better. And the good news about Christians, by the way, is we have so much material to do better. Totally like a taken read. Yeah.

Speaker 2: I mean, I, when I, when I've spoken on Christian nationalism, one of the things I usually bring up is like the Barman confession, the Barman confession to me, it's like, what a beautiful, like it's short, it's succinct. I realized Bart probably wrote the whole thing. Um, but there was a group of people there and you just look back at it and you're like, yeah, this is more the trajectory we need to be on. We need to sort of meditate on this and trying to understand how to enact something of these thoughts in our current situation. So Yeah. Great explanation there. Yeah.

Speaker 1: If I can play a kind of armchair theologian pastor for.

Speaker 2: Just 100 percent, you know, I'll.

Speaker 1: Say, you know, the problem is not that we as Christians disagree about these materials. The problem is that we as Christians have never read them. Yeah. Right. Yeah. It's tabula rasa. It's a blank slate. When I speak to college students, when I'm in churches having these same conversations, it's not that, oh, well, I don't agree with Bart on this. Oh, well, I don't agree with Kuyper on that. They've never heard of. There's no point. We're not having disagreements. It's just a blank slate. We're being introduced to Bart and Kiefer.

Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1: No, it's the first time. It's the first time. And okay, well, great. At least we don't have to surmount the hill of, well, I've read it and considered it and disagreed with it. But we do have to, in a way, almost go back to the very beginning of catechesis and say, well, okay, my friends, I believe in God, the Father Almighty, creator of heaven and earth. We're going right credibly back.

Speaker 2: To the beginning.

Speaker 1: Because i think we've lost and and i think it's true the evangelical church generally of which i include my own christian reform church we've just quit the field on these confessions and these creeds and these documents and it's been a great tragedy for the church because uh you know i know we over intellectualize the faith you know there was there was too much emphasis on doctrine well we have swept out the devil of doctrine and seven worst devils have come in right of.

Speaker 2: And now I think we might.

Speaker 1: Need to recover doctrine as not a four-letter word, but actually as hallelujah, as a gift to us in this moment.

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, at the risk of getting off track, I guess I'm going to take the risk. A buddy of mine has been talking about this issue of catechesis and teaching office. So he does a lot of Reformation stuff. And so he thinks in terms of the teaching office. And one of the problems we've kind of diagnosed is we have what we're calling reactive catechesis. So you have these moments where some sort of theological quote unquote scandal is, you know, arises, you know, some popular Christian YouTuber says something a little bit off the cuff and then the white blood cells sort of surround them and they try to explain all these doctrines. And it's just such a fascinating phenomenon to watch because I'm like, shouldn't we know this already?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Like we should already have been girded up for that defense, like so that this just sort of pings off the armor and we realize, oh, this guy doesn't know what he's talking about. This woman doesn't know what she's talking about or whatever. But we don't. We have to do it in reaction. And so you start building this sort of ad hoc set of doctrines that may or may not be coherent, very much often aren't, and that have an awful lot of holes in them. And so I agree with you 100 percent there. I think I agree. I think that the nationalists have something that they are trying to to sort of crystallize, but that our dearth of understanding of the Christian tradition really hurts us in those conversations. Let me address this last thing and then we'll close out the episodes. I know we're getting close to time. Favorite title of the whole book. Um, chapter 12, uh, conclusion, the poly apocalypse is for lovers. Um, just give it, just give it like two minutes and explain that chapter to folks. I thought I was reading through the chapter titles. I was like, dude, this is going to be an amazing book if this is way it's ending. So that's great.

Speaker 1: Well, well, it's actually, so it's, it's, it's based on an earlier book that my, uh, uh, friend, Alyssa Wilkinson and I write, she's now a New York times film critic called how to survive the apocalypse. Zombies, Cylons, Faith and Politics at the End of the World. So that was kind of the riff there. But I mean, the idea is that when you have... So this is the problem with not just the apocalypse. We're talking about World War III. We're talking about AI ending all life on Earth. We're talking about near-Earth orbit, the weaponization of near-Earth orbit, plagues, pathogens. I think we've more or less... stopped talking about climate, planetary boundaries. So even if that's on your list, or if you don't like it, well, don't worry, because it's way down there. Nobody's talking about it anymore. So the problem is that the speed and the number, the quantity and the speed of apocalyptic problems now coming at our politics is so frenzied that I think in some ways we have no recourse to than to rediscover identity. I think that's one of the reasons why our identity politics are so fraught and so fierce, because we need to know what we love and who we are in order to understand the trade-offs, right? Why ought I to choose this? Why ought we to do that, right? What are the possibilities here? And that requires us to be, I think it pushes us, and in a way, I mean, this is actually maybe, you know, a bit of the good news. The crisis pushes us, the overlapping nature of these crises, these permanent crises, force us out of complacency, right? I think it's Neil Ferguson sort of made this argument and I made it in the pathology of the tragedy of the commons chapter as well, that there are certain societies that seem to perform better because their national politics seem to perform better, particularly under moments of national stress and crisis. because they're just more accustomed. They're more serious in their politics, right? Actually, Max Brooks in his book, World War Z, which I loved and had signed from about the zombie apocalypse and so on.

Speaker 2: Yeah, really good book.

Speaker 1: He has this fictional sort of thing too, where he says, well, actually some of these societies did better. Why? Because they were accustomed, you know, South Korea, Taiwan, Israel. Why do they do better? Because they're accustomed to making life and death decisions very quickly on a very regular basis. So they know who they are, or if they don't know who they are, as by the way, the Israelis are in the middle of relitigating As we speak, having just voted. Right. So maybe by the time this this episode airs, they'll actually have a government. But I don't know. I think it'll take a while. Right. Why do they have you know, you go you go to an Israeli academic conference or you have debates with Israelis. You think, my gosh, these people are really coming at me like they've got they've got some strong opinions. They're very vigorous about because they're right on the edge.

Speaker 2: That's right.

Speaker 1: They don't they don't have time to kind of, you know, Michigan nice their way around the problem. Right. I they're they're they're living on the end of a demilitarized zone. They're living across a strait with a big belligerent geopolitical power that's coming to sort of. So, I mean, you know, there's a very clarifying aspect to the way those are. This is one of the reasons why Max Brooks says the Israelis do very well in his fictionalized zombie apocalypse, you know, because, you know, they they they go through the kind of intelligence gathering process, you know, and this and they're they're enormously serious. The problem with, and I won't stick it to the United States here, I'll stick it to my own home country where I was born, Canada. The problem with countries like Canada is we just don't need to be that serious, right? We are so rich and so big and everything is so nice. And honestly, we didn't even really have to worry about our own security until about yesterday, right? It was different in World War II, but for the last 80 years or so, there was a difference. character to that. And so one of the frustrating things as somebody who worked in Canadian politics before I actually became a professor, one of the frustrating things is that there is a fundamentally unserious nature to some of these crises, because we know we can take them seriously. We cannot take them seriously. It doesn't really matter. We're going to be fine. We got lots, we got lots of money. We got lots of land. We got lots of fresh water, right? Climate change. It's going to be great for Canada, right? You know, we're going to crush it. You know, we got lots of fossil fuels, you know, we got lots of stuff going on up there. And unfortunately, it makes us very deeply unserious people. And what it means is that we don't need the trade-offs. We don't need to think as seriously about what we love because we can kind of have it all, right? We can be a bit unserious about it. We can kind of have it all. I now think, and part of the trauma that's afflicting Canadians today and Europeans to another degree, and Americans to a certain extent, but it's not news to Israelis. It's not news to Taiwan. It's not news to South Korea either. is that we're now moving out of that very soft and gentle world where we don't need to be particularly serious. And so it's causing a crisis of confidence and a crisis of identity because now we need to choose. We just can't choose one of everything that's on the menu. You know, we'll have national pharma care and universal health care and 5% of our GDP dedicated toward defense. Ah, and we'll run deficits as high as the sky is. And it won't matter because our economy is so competitive and we're so rich that we'll probably grow our way out of those deficits and the debt won't be very much out of control. Well, that bill has come due to. So now we have trade-offs. And the trade-offs are hard. They put us in touch as a nature of these crises. They have to put us in touch with who we are and what we really love. We have to start putting our money where our mouth is because we can't just do a little bit of everything to avoid the fight. So now we're fighting. And on some level, again, I actually say this as an encouragement because it makes our politics more serious and it reminds us who we really are. We probably need we're overdue for a good fight. Right. We're overdue for a good conflict about some of these tradeoffs.

Speaker 2: It's not a bad. Yeah, it's not a bad thing. Totally. I always go back to Albert Borgman. He wrote a book on technology and culture, if you are familiar with that. And so, you know, we've you know, in his language, we've been a nation. We've been nations, I would say, United States and Canada. We've been nations that have been living in sort of a device paradigm where we just get things. Everything's commoditized. It's easy for us to get things. We don't really have to struggle that much. And we're moving back into a thing sort of existence where we're going to have to struggle and work and go through a process. But in going through that process, yes, there will be difficulties along the way, but it does forge a different sort of character and it forges a different sort of community. than do the ease and luxury that decadence often brings. I think that's a beautiful way to characterize it. Well, man, this has been a great conversation. It feels like we could go for another hour, but we probably shouldn't. And so I just want to thank you for being on the show. Thanks for the book. This is fantastic. Really appreciate it. Everybody out there, the title of the book, again, is Christ and Covenant in Global Politics. This is an IVP Press book. So you'll see the link to the book in the show description, as well as a 20% discount code if you order off IVP Press website. So I'd encourage you to do that. Great book. Actually, really, I think accessible read for a book on global politics. And so I encourage you to go pick this up. And yeah, thanks, Robert, for being here. This is fantastic.

Speaker 1: Yeah, thanks for having me. This was a lot of fun.

Speaker 2: Absolutely. All right, everybody. Well, take care and we'll catch on the next episode of Thinking Christian. Just want to take a second to thank the team at Life Audio for their partnership with us on the Thinking Christian podcast. If you go to lifeaudio.com, you'll find dozens of other faith-centered podcasts in their network. They've got shows about prayer, Bible study, parenting, and more.

Keep listening

New episodes twice weekly.

Calm, thoughtful, theological conversations for uncompromising faith.