Article

Praying Near Power: What the White House Easter Lunch Revealed

By James Spencer Last updated

Introduction

The trappings that come with proximity to power aren’t new. When Christian leaders are given access to the halls of government and invited to speak, pray, and stand alongside those who govern, they have both an opportunity and a temptation. They have the opportunity to speak truthfully to power and to offer faithful testimony to the Triune God. They can remind those who govern that their authority is delegated and limited. It is a gift to be exercised for good, reflecting, however dimly, the righteous judgment of the Lord. They may also be tempted to let the privilege of access fool them into thinking that the political agendas they share with sitting presidents or other leaders reflect God’s will. The temptation is to believe that God is so aligned with a given administration that its leaders are granted a legitimacy that precludes real criticism and to baptize that belief into the language of providence.

This temptation is similar to that highlighted by James Findlay in his comment on the relationship between “evangelical denominations and business leaders” in the mid-1800s. Though he recognizes the benefits of that relationship, he also suggests that the growing dependence of the church on businessmen “made it difficult for evangelical leaders to criticize the business community, even if they [evangelicals] so desired.” If we believe political leaders are “on a mission from God” like the Blues Brothers or that the church is somehow dependent on those leaders for its ongoing existence or ongoing comfort, what possible reason would we have to criticize them?

The temptation tends to be dressed in genuine conviction, long-standing relationships, so-called Christian values and concerns, and a reasonable desire to maintain influence and to guide leaders spiritually. This approach can produce a particular kind of theological language that sounds robustly Christian, draws on Scripture, invokes God’s name, but has actually lost its theological depth. The words remain, but the meaning changes.

An Easter lunch hosted at the White House on April 1, 2026, provides a clear example of this sort of language. The event brought together more than one hundred faith leaders for prayer and remarks in the presence of the president. Several prominent “faith leaders,” including Robert Jeffress, Paula White-Cain, and Franklin Graham, offered the sort of theological framing that has become familiar in certain Christian circles close to Trump’s administration and common in conservative political circles more generally. A fourth voice, Bishop Robert Barron, offered something notably different.

Before engaging the specific remarks, it is worth noting that there is nothing necessarily wrong with Christian leaders attending such an event, praying for the president, or participating in our nation’s civic life. That kind of engagement has a long and honorable history. Reflexive suspicion or rejection of it reflects a political rather than a theological instinct. The question is not whether Christians should pray for those who govern, but how those prayers reflect the Christian conviction that we are dependent on the Triune God whose ways we don’t always understand.

Paula White-Cain: The Gospel Reshaped

White-Cain’s comments had some of the more obvious problems and drew sharp criticism after the luncheon. In addition to suggesting that Trump is a great warrior for faith in the United States, she went on to draw a connection between Jesus and Trump, noting:

“Jesus taught so many lessons through his death, burial and resurrection. He showed us great leadership, great transformation requires great sacrifice. And Mr. President, no one has paid the price like you have paid the price. It almost cost you your life…You were betrayed and arrested and falsely accused. It’s a familiar pattern that our Lord and Savior showed us. But it didn’t end there for him, and it didn’t end there for you. God always had a plan. On the third day, he rose. He defeated evil. He conquered death, hell and the grave. Because he rose, we all know we can rise, and, sir, because of his resurrection you rose up…I believe that the Lord said to tell you this: Because of his victory, you will be victorious in all you put your hand to.”

Reactions from Christians across the spectrum were swift and sharply negative, with multiple theologians and ministry leaders describing the remarks as blasphemous or heretical. Those reactions are appropriate, yet the depth of the theological mistake still needs to be mined.

White-Cain compared Trump to an unnuanced Jesus. In her framing, Christ’s death, burial, and resurrection serve as a template for resilience under political pressure. Suffering leads to vindication. Sacrifice produces victory. The pattern is emotionally resonant, but far from theological.

The crucifixion and resurrection of Christ are not primarily a story about enduring temporal political opposition and prevailing. At their theological core, they are an act of self-giving love rooted in obedience to the Father and oriented toward the redemption of humanity. Jesus bore the judgment that humanity deserved in order to usher in the kingdom of God. That kingdom is not established through temporal political administration. It is a reality that we recognize as we contemplate Christ’s sacrificial death and resurrection.

White-Cain either assumes or ignores the underlying dynamic of obedience to the Father’s will, of suffering as a Christian (1 Pet 4:16). In doing so, she can frame Trump as a Jesus figure without the pesky baggage that often comes with theological precision. Trump struggled and prevailed. He will continue to be victorious. This is the logic of the prosperity gospel applied to political outcomes rather than financial ones: earthly success is evidence of divine favor. Given that logic, one wonders what sitting president it couldn’t be applied to.

Franklin Graham: The Misread Text

Graham’s contribution to the Easter lunch was a prayer comparing the current conflict with Iran to the biblical book of Esther and suggesting that Donald Trump arose for “such a time as this” (Est 4:14).

The problems with this reading are both historical and theological. Regarding the historical challenge, the Persians of Esther’s era (5th c. BC) were likely Zoroastrian, not Muslim. The Islamic identity Graham associated with modern Iran is separated from Xerxes’ court by more than 2,500 years (the Islamic conquest of Persia didn’t occur until the early- to mid-600s AD, with the more modern Iranian identity, including the Islamic republic, established in 1979). These are not trivial errors, but symptoms of a deeper misreading and misuse of Esther.

The deeper misreading involves the more basic message of the book of Esther. The book narrates a crisis arising within the Persian court, not a Persian military campaign against the Jewish people. Haman, the story’s villain, is an Agagite. He is often regarded as a descendant of Agag (1 Sam 15:8), who was the king of the Amalekites. The Amalekites attacked Israel shortly after the Exodus (Exod 17:8-16), prompting God to curse Amalek (Deut 25:17-19; 1 Sam 15:1-3). Haman represents one of the final remnants of the Amalekites who have opposed God’s people from the very beginning. The Persians are portrayed as pawns manipulated by Haman as part of a longstanding rivalry between Israel and the Amalekites that ends with the death of Haman (Est 7:7-10). The book speaks to God’s ongoing care of his people even in exile and, likely, serves as something of a cautionary tale and critique of Israel’s past unwillingness to blot out the memory of Amalek (1 Sam 15:7-9).

The phrase Graham invokes, “such a time as this,” comes from Mordecai’s challenge to Esther (4:14). He is not declaring divine favor on a military campaign but calling Esther to consider that God may have placed her in the king’s court so that she could risk her own life by interceding on their behalf. The phrase opens the question of divine providence and the way that God has positioned Esther to ensure the survival of the Jews in Persia. Applying this language to President Trump is, on some generic level, appropriate. God places all people in specific positions for his use. Yet, the use of this language goes beyond a more general notion of providence. The phrase “such a time as this” has arguably become a slogan denoting a peculiar sort of courage Christians exercise in the face of difficulties. It is a way of suggesting some form of heroism and virtue. Thus, in applying the phrase to President Trump for engaging in combat with Iran, Graham is not-so-subtly assuming that President Trump is a virtuous hero willing to do the work of God by protecting his people via the war in Iran. Given the other interpretive problems evident in Graham’s remarks, his claim that Trump was made president for “such a time as this” is difficult to accept as a reasonable theological statement.

What Graham did in the prayer was less interpretation and more appropriation. He took a text about faithful vulnerability under foreign power and pressed it into service as divine authorization for American military efforts. The result is not a plausible interpretation of Esther but a replacement of the book’s message with the message Graham wants to celebrate in the moment.

Beyond the immediate political context, this kind of reading trains Christian audiences to reach for biblical language that confers an exaggerated significance and authorization while ignoring what the text actually says. Prayer that appropriates Scripture for political celebration rather than engaging it honestly is not prayer shaped by God’s word. It is prayer that shapes God’s word to fit our conceptions of what is good, true, and beautiful.

Robert Jeffress: Overreading God’s Appointment

Jeffress tends to apply the language of divine authorization to the United States and to Donald Trump specifically. I deal with his assertion that America is a Christian nation and his misapplication of Ps 33:12 in *Serpents and Doves*. His remarks at the Easter luncheon were consistent with the broader understanding he articulates elsewhere.

Jeffress describes a conversation he had with Trump prior to his election, noting, “I said, ‘Mr. Trump, I believe God has appointed you to be the next president of the United States. And if that happens, it’s because he has a plan for you and for our country.’” He goes on to say, “…who would have ever thought that a billionaire real estate tycoon from New York City would usher in a spiritual revival of the United States.”

The first claim, taken in isolation and in the abstract, is theologically defensible. Romans 13:1-4 makes clear that God appoints all the leaders of every country for the purpose of encouraging goodness and exercising judgment. Scripture describes Nebuchadnezzar as God’s servant (Jer 25:9; 27:6; 43:10) and Cyrus as God’s shepherd (Isa 44:28) and God’s anointed (45:1). God uses rulers for his purposes, but that use does not legitimize everything a ruler does, nor does it insulate them from accountability. For instance, God will hold Babylon accountable for their treatment of God’s people even after using Babylon as an instrument of judgment (Jer 25:12).

While the general theological point may be correct, there is a reason that Jeffress doesn’t apply the same sort of language to other politicians like former president Joe Biden or James Talarico. When Jeffress says Trump is ushering in a “spiritual revival,” he isn’t simply reaffirming Romans 13:1-4. Jeffress is making a political statement by claiming to know how God is using Donald Trump. His language moves from a general theological claim to a more specific one because the specificity fits a narrative he wants to see advanced. Again, we see that the language elevates this particular president and God’s plans for him in ways that are intended to encourage loyalty to the president and his administration.

This is where the language becomes most dangerous. A president understood as divinely appointed for national revival is a president whose failures are easy to overlook, whose critics become adversaries of God’s purposes, and whose supporters have theological warrant for a practically unqualified allegiance. Jeffress has not simply affirmed what God’s word says about nations and leaders but has endowed this particular leader with a specific mission from God that looks suspiciously like a conservative political agenda.

Bishop Barron: A Bright Spot

Barron’s invocation was centered, from its opening lines, not on the president but on Christ. He addressed God as “provident Lord of history” and devoted the bulk of his prayer to the person of Jesus. When he turned to the nation and its leaders, the grammar of the prayer shifted from celebration to petition. He prayed that the nation would be “prosperous and safe,” but above all “morally upright.” The reference to morality makes clear that there is a reality that has a claim on all of us, even the president. We are to live in accordance with that reality and, as such, Barron prayed that the president would receive “the grace, the courage, the wisdom, and the prudence he needs to perform his duties according to your [God’s] will.”

Barron prays that God will give the president what he needs to act according to God’s will rather than assuming the president is already aligned with God’s will. Instead of celebrating current decisions as if they are already aligned with God’s purposes, Barron asks God to “clothe us with his compassion, his meekness, his love for the poor,” making Christ the standard against which national life and leadership is to be measured, rather than making national success the measure of God’s blessing. Barron asked God to intervene, to refine, and to shape the president, to work in him rather than simply working through him.

Conclusion

White-Cain, Graham, and Jeffress are prominent voices within the conservative religious movement. The posture they modeled at Easter will likely influence many Christians and shape the way they understand the relationship between faith and political power.

The problem is not political participation. We should pray for our leaders. The problem is an orientation that assumes God must be behind a given leader because that leader’s agenda aligns with our own or because our nation seems to be “winning.” That assumption forecloses the very submission, humility, and openness to divine correction that faithful prayer requires. The people of Babylon likely believed their gods (or the God) were on their side at the peak of the empire. They were wrong. God is certainly directing our nation, but we don’t know exactly how or why.

When the church and its leaders believe it needs a particular politician or that a particular politician is uniquely God’s instrument to usher in a moment of spiritual renewal, the capacity for honest theological witness erodes. That erosion doesn’t happen all at once. It happens over time as we ignore the language chosen, accept that certain questions shouldn’t be raised, and pray to affirm our political agendas rather than pursuing God’s will.

Prayer that asks God for what a leader still needs is different from prayer that assumes the leader can do no wrong, or no wrong that really matters. The first holds the leader accountable to something beyond himself. The second makes God accountable for the leader’s choices. Only one of those belongs in the Christian tradition. The Easter lunch featured both, and the difference between them was not subtle.

By James Spencer, PhD, theologian and host of the Thinking Christian podcast. His forthcoming book is Digital Discernment: Thinking Rightly in an Age of Misinformation (InterVarsity Press, forthcoming June 2027). About James